How Much Do We Need To Spend To Hear What CD/SACD or Vinyl Really Has To Offer. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Yes, but SACD's extend far above redbook. Home. It lacks the deep bass of the Abkco pressing but sounds so much more "vivid" and real. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. After purchasing The Cars S/T, Candy-O, and Shake It Up on MFSL vinyl, here are my thoughts. For many multi-channel enthusiasts the answer is yes, because that is what they care about most. If you want to try SACD on a budget (relatively), the Sony UBP-X800M2 Blu-Ray player plays SACDs (as well as DVD Audio, which does high-res surround). Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. #4. . Boy, what a difference. Slight increase in frequency range and they also have a lot more features on the Blu-ray disc that are fun to play with. A Secret Lab. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. Since this mess I want to compare more where I have overlap. SACD disc and the DSD encoding (on a SACD) are a "frozen in time" tech circa 2005. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me. 10/disc royalty for CDs. Consequently, the Super Audio CD (SACD) was developed by Philips and Sony. ) Reel-to-reel can be better, but tapes are fragile and rare, then the players have been out of production for decades and require expensive maintenance from. If it's a hi-res source of unknown origin it will simply say "HR". The SACD is wonderful sounding reworking, giving the very believable and acceptable illusion that the original recording was pretty good. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. Description. The vinyl has a noise rise and a peak around 30 kHz. In the vinyl vs. By Paul Sinclair. Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. The internet has not only changed. Although this recording was digital, the Parsons 2017 remaster actually sounds more analogue than the original cd. One more thing. There were two Marantz SACD players I was keeping my eye on: the 30n ($2999) and the SA-KI Ruby Signature player with DAC ($3999). The SACD I found is always better, that’s if you have the right SACD player like the DMP. 7 to 8. Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. I have to disagree with the positive remarks of the SACD's. Vinyl is better than CD because it reproduces higher frequencies than CD and avoids anti-aliasing filter issues at the frequencies CDs can reproduce. 24. To address a few questions; there are two seperate series, stereo and Mono in the Prestige SACD series, each with unique titles. Audiogon The world's largest high-end audio community. Quote: Originally Posted by FenderP To me, it's not about formats. I like both; but am buying more hi-q vinyl than SACD, DVD-A, or HDCD simply because remastered 180g vinyl is easier to find in the genres I listen to: Rock, alt-rock, blues, some jazz, and oldies. Would someone out there who has the vinyl and has compared it to either the MFSL CD or the newer SACD please. Vinyl. Still waiting form "Brothers in Arms" on SACD I have also ordered the MoFi vinyl releases of: "Love Over Gold", "Dire Straits" and "Brothers in Arms" I look forward to comparing SACD vs Vinyl *reelspin* My thought process is I should buy them while they are relatively new and prices have not reached $200+ each yet. The SACD is definitely much more forward and vivid across the board, with ringing steel strings and a real bite to the violin. The initial presentation changed from relatively mechanical to one with atmosphere and naturalness. Blue Note sacds), I already have records of. I'm generally rather selective about my SACD purchases and only have about 25-30SACD recordings now although I plan to order a lot more as more and more reissues come out. Share Jun 15, 2007 at 8:50 AM Post #29 of 33 Forest Design 100+ Head-Fier. Even better than the regular SACD with even clearer presentation. Tom Favata, Apr 9, 2021. New items New comments Author list Series Latest content Latest updates Latest reviews. Ironically, the royalty for an SACD was the same as for a CD: $. There are very few times I like the CD better than the LP. Then I bought the new SACD version. The SACD format supports multiple audio channels, a very high digital sampling rate, and longer playing time. While the standard CD format is tied to a 44. I find that SACD offers more detail and a deeper, wider soundstage and better instrument timbre over CD. 45 RPM 200 Gram Clarity Vinyl. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. . Way. Thread Status: Not open for further replies. Los Angeles, CA. disc duplication: The Indie Music Minute. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. The band's incendiary…I agree to a point, but "everything matters" and adding an well built, linear power supply to my source made a subtle but very, very noticeable improvement as did cableing, power cables, isolation, etc. " DeTurk is a big advocate. Forums. Following a change in how Billboard counts sales in 2009, it re-entered the chart and has since appeared for over 900 weeks. Never the SACD player as a SACD player vs a dedicated CD player with the same SACD hybrid disc. SACD or BluRay or good old fashioned CD's will never have the back catalog that vinyl has if your willing to dig through the crates. 6%. 98: Grateful Dead / Workingman's Dead Hybrid Stereo SACD Numbered Limited Edition CMOB 2137 SA Original Price: $29. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. The SACD I found is always better, that’s if you have the right SACD player like the DMP. The band did NOT like it at all. That leaves Soft Parade which also was released by Audio Fidelity. Quick links. SACD vs. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Mobile Fidelity Gold CD 1988. Nantes, France. Sign in with Google Even the standard redbook CD (44kHz, 16 bit resolution) has about a 26dB advantage to vinyl with respect to dynamic range, and at least a 40-50 dB advantage in stereo separation as well as unmeasurable wow and flutter. On the one hand, Norah Jone's 2012 Come Away with Me SACD has better overall sound quality (dynamic range, detail, etc. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Audiogon The world's largest high-end audio community. IGNORED Shootout: 24 bit vs. Super Audio CD (SACD) is an optical disc format for audio storage introduced in 1999. Likewise whichever has the edge in your playback system will be superior to the. I always remember the SACD being pretty good, but I now think the vinyl destroys it. Moody Blues "Question of bal. I sampled a bunch of SACDs and kept finding differences that were attributable to different mastering and. On a CD, the separation between the left and right channels used in recording is over 90 dB. If you like those genres then I can support jumping into SACD's in 2022. tlake6659 said: ↑. If. The difference between 24/192 and DSD is that the DSD sounds more analog like, but this is not a huge difference in overall sound quality. There is some technology that JVC uses to make the. When Analogue Productions announced it would be releasing Bernie Grundman-mastered versions of the complete Steely Dan catalog on vinyl and SACD, audiophiles rejoiced. Under perfect circumstances, SACD provides an incremental improvement over CD. . . There are records for every genre of music I listen to, whereas almost nothing I listen to is ever released on SACD. Sure it has a tint, but what doesn't? Vinyl has a tint. Bach's St Matthew's Passion. I like Analogue Productions' work, so it should be interesting to hear how they sound. I wrote I was somewhat pleased with the mastering. It is now showing as ‘in stock’ on the Acoustic Sounds. Location: KC Chiefs Kingdom. 1kHz/16-bit digital audio is indistinguishable from high-resolution digital. And I'm not all that hot on CDs. In my experience, 96/24 is only slightly better than 44/16. After that, what format is it available in? And which represents the best mastering? It's as simple as that. Disagree. Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. I compared the 2003 SACD and the Mofi: the noise is certainly clearer on the Mofi, but it's present on the 2003. Roxanne Joncas Soundstage determines the stereo image width you perceive between the speakers. Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. If you like SACDs, the 2004 reissue of Relaxin’ by the Miles Davis Quintet sounds equally fantastic, albeit a little different with a. Truth is, there aren't really any bad sounding versions of this moody gem since the first pressing back in spring 1971. The following are not reviews in any way—nothing I say really matters. However, play the SACD mono mix (or Sundazed mono vinyl-whatever you've got) on a half decent stereo system today and all the heavy compression, notch EQ-ing, and tricks he had to pull are exposed: the vocals are generally cranked up, that tambourine is really loud, and Crosby's rhythm guitar is generally buried in the mix. In. )I don't have the SACD (it's too expensive and I'm only capable of stereo). Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by fluffskul, Apr 26, 2012. garfish. The data is read by a laser, and then decoded to produce audio playback. It's ok if you like 'that' sound. But I don't have an LP with the exact same mastering as an SACD so I can't do any type of apples-to-apples comparison (and even then equipment comes in to play). kevintomb Forum Resident. I much prefer CD to SACD. 192 is significantly better and DXD (352) is even better. Voted Vinyl. Two of the discs were mastered in MQA and two were SACD. I was still unconvinced. . SACD vs. 1. g. SACD is a very nice addition if you maintain a decent stationary rig anyway. I did a similar shoot out to yours above with the sax and vocal section at the end of Avalon with the SACD and UK first press vinyl. The best of both worlds is vinyl ripped on a very high end rig in High res and then converted to DSD. Not making "excuses" for SACD, just making a point. Both formats offer unique qualities that appeal to discerning music enthusiasts, and the choice between them often comes down to personal preference and the pursuit of sonic perfection. Gooey black bag houses an extremely high quality record sleeve with postcards, posters, 320 kbps MP3 download and sturdy inner sleeve and a very nice vinyl record in a plastic sleeve. Bluebook The right price. This is the reason why Pink Floyd did NOT consider Alan Parsons. The 777ES does not perform at its best upon power-on. Thankfully my vinyl copy of that album is pristine. Please login or register an accountlogin or register an accountSACD vs CD-do you listen and compare SACD/CD layers on your discs? Discussion in 'Music Corner' started by BSC, Apr 13, 2015. Compared to the vinyl, more rounded, less real. Vinyl. The category "Outstanding" doesn't mean audiophile sound, but outstanding quality compared to original pressings. . Bluebook The right price. Mastered: Doug Sax, James Guthrie, Joel Plante. The discs are digitally identical and will sound exactly the same no matter what some snake oil lovers will tell you. Tullman, Jul 31,. label will be coming to hybrid stereo SACD (playable on all CD players) as well as to audiophile-standard UltraDisc One-Step 180-gram, 45 RPM vinyl. I no longer have the capability of playing vinyl. Vinyl. Id agree with the guy about the old cd and sacd not being *that* much different other than a bit more resolution. " CD or SACD vs Vinyl. That means engineers have a much narrower range to work with when they’re mixing and mastering the audio, and the result, for the listener, is that the stereo “image” is highly constricted. Whereas some others where I am pretty familiar with it's vinyl 'equivalent' I could tell even without direct comparison that the vinyl was better, like Kind of Blue for example. In the vinyl vs. Boy, what a difference. This is why CDs sample sound at 44. . SACD obviously has an advantage on portability and probably overall SQ - but that's still subjective as I might enjoy the "colorization" of vinyl more. I've heard to the contrary, that the QUAD version. On LPs, it’s 30 dB at best. Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. DVD-Audio vs Vinyl vs. Tip about the 1812, the first cannon shot is the toughest of the lot to track, that one is a beastie (the Shure V 15 Type IV mounted on a SME III tonearm came closest in the day, or the Audio-Technica 440 ML). Vinyl has more. Team Value-Fi. Have GFTO on SACD and the Yes 1968 - 1987 Studio Boxset on CD. ssmith3046, Nov 28, 2012 #4. I just listened closely to the MFSL SACD, the noises are audible at the end of every track. I don’t care what they claim they did to the CD. Fred Dender and Grampire like this. Price $3,499. . Durability: SACDs are more durable and resistant to scratches compared to vinyl records. When it comes to listening to music, there are two main formats that audiophiles swear by: SACD players and vinyl. Alan Blumlien of EMI in the 1930’s patented analog stereo, to be first used on. . I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. First I played my vinyl copy yesterday and found it be exquisite. The Rhino and Audio Fidelity releases are the same mix, but different masterings. BD Pure Audio is basically the same as DVD-A except it's encoded to 96/24. Location: West Hollywood, CA and Inverness, IL. I voted 'Who Cares. I grew up in the analogue days (vinyl and tape) so tape hiss is to be expected on recordings. On the Analogue Productions SACD,. Just trust your ears, as I do mine. Luke theorizes that the 2003 SACD and the MFSL were sourced from an LP cutting master and that the original master mixes were used on the Biograph and GHII remasters. 1 layer is very good, but the SACD layer has smoother high frequencies (violins, oboe) and better transient attack (tympani). Forums. Home. 1 remixes which I love. Merch Rep the community and hobby you love so much. Also my opinion only. CD: SACD’s high resolution and dynamic range typically exceed those of standard CDs, resulting in a potentially more detailed and accurate listening experience. Stereophile SACD test Hi everybody, I've just joined this forum after reading this thread on the Stereophile test. It is now showing as ‘in stock’ on the Acoustic Sounds. I voted 'Who Cares. The separation between the left and right channels on vinyl is 30dB, compared to digital files, which exceed 90 dB. CCR SACD vs new vinyl. The MoFi also has surface noise,while the Abkco vinyl is near silent. Virtual Systems Let the world see what you've built. Moody Blues "Question of bal. SACD’s technical advantages, high resolution, dynamic range, and low noise. On the vinyl, the violin and the acoustic rhythm guitar lay back a bit, and there's a slightly rounded-off, woody tone to the drumming and the bass, and a very, very subtle tunneled, recessed quality to the vocals. 98: Whitney Houston / Whitney. Sucks that there's no general concensus as to which CD is better, aside from the SACD. Vinyl for me. The DVD Forum, headed by Toshiba, refused to pay patent royalties to Sony and Philips, and they launched a competing format: DVD-Audio, which couldn’t be played in a CD player. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. The individual versions will be available on September 16, 2022 with the Deluxe version available from October 7, 2022. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. ? How Much Do We Need To Spend To Hear High Quality CD/SACD or Vinyl Reproduction. The standard CD format is a 2-channel, 16-bit, 44. The SACD format allows multiple audio channels (i. The 2003 hybrid SACD and the MFSL feature the original mix, but they have inferior sound to the JWH tracks which appear on the 1997 Biograph remaster and the 1999 GHII remaster. In other words, it sounds like continuous noise on the tape which is mainly audible between the tracks, and MFSL decided not to fade it out. KevinP, May 21, 2009 #52. Even as a purist I am very happy with the results. CD has a tint. According to a theorem called. The gap. Well as I might have expected the SACD was the best. They all sound great but I really can't say that the SHM-SACD sounds better than the other two. Cardioid microphones are a good choice for general-purpose recording and live sound reinforcement, while supercardioid microphones are better suited for more challenging environments where there is a lot of ambient noise and the sound source needs to be isolated more tightly. If you like those genres then I can support jumping into SACD's in 2022. My DCC is definitly better. Note the. Of the core six Doors records, I only have original-ish pressings of the middle three ( Waiting For The Sun, The Soft Parade, Morrison Hotel ). The best of both worlds is vinyl ripped on a very high end rig in High res and then converted to DSD. I no longer have the capability of playing vinyl. #13. But when I compare the same piece issued both on SACD and vinyl (Channel Records, Pentatone), SACD carries the day by a whisker: a touch airier, a slightly truer tone and yes, an even better “flow” that facilitate following the musical argument. ”. Vinyl. SACD sounds damn nice, there are LOTS of them available and new SACD's of material that interests me continue to be released. The quantization noise floor for 16-bit digital audio (the CD standard) is -96 dB, each bit yielding 6 dB of headroom between the noise floor and the ceiling. Mirror Image, Sep 16, 2022. View entire discussion. Both are also 4K UHD Blu-Ray players. swanlee, Dec 8, 2012. I don't know which is more truthful. This album can sound really good. Fourth - 45 rpm vinyl . The Dark Side of the Moon produced two singles: "Money" and "Us and Them. " CD or SACD vs Vinyl. SACD vs. Then I bought the new SACD version. I do have an unwrapped Cramberries (best of) SHM CD with me. some of the older quadrophonic recordings now being reissued), or are pieces which were designed for surround sound (e. But Sony is almost 4 times more. True. • The first international release of the recording on Hybrid SACDs, allowing listeners to hear the enhanced resolution of these new transfers and playable on all CD players • The first and only complete Wagner Ring cycle available in Dolby Atmos Channel separation. You can’t go wrong there. Warner Music [Sony Music outside Europe] today announced the upcoming release of Pink Floyd’s ‘Animals’ on Deluxe Gatefold, CD, LP, Blu-ray and SACD. net (24. SHM-SACD vs original CD (WB), vs original vinyl (WB) I first cleaned each vinyl LP on my NG 1. This first example compares MoFi' s Music From Big Pink - LP vs. Elton John Elton John (2004 Rocket SACD HR B0003607-36) All the Elton John SACD's sound incredible. " CD or SACD vs Vinyl. Link to comment Share on other sites. The real advantage of a (multichannel) SACD player is the ability to listen to the surround sound recording. The higher resolution of the blu ray might also explain the audible tape hiss not heard on the cd. SACD vs VINYL. e. During the summer I don't get much seat time in front of the stereo so it might be a week or more before my next chance. I've heard to the contrary, that the QUAD version. The vinyl appears to be analogue mastered so if you value an all-analogue chain that would be an advantage. DeepDiscount has 1/25 as the release date. Thread: SACD Vs. Every time. I have a few titles on both vinyl, r2r, cd and SACD. . SACD vs. Oh and if you like SACDs, most of the masters were made on digital audio workstations that are PCM. I do have two different versions of "Question of Balance". Thread Status: Not open for further replies. However, I think it's still too early to answer this question even with identically mastered sources recorded and played back on state-of-the-art equipment optimized for. Thread Tools. One is the MFSL version which I loved. 1% $750-$1,000 15 vote(s) 8. . Actually, probably the biggest difference that I have seen with the SACD format. Vinyl. vinyl superior to both? thats been conjectured. One is the MFSL version which I loved. While vinyl records, in theory, directly encode a smooth audio wave, CDs sample that audio wave at various points and then collate those samples. On September 16th Analogue Productions announced they will reissue the entire ABC/MCA Records Steely Dan catalog on SACD, and 45rpm UHQR LP, beginning November 4th with their debut album Can't Buy A Thrill, now in its 50th anniversary year. SACD VS Vinyl for Jazz and Classical Well, I've been thinking of getting into vinyl for a while now but still haven't done it. During that time, my analog front end has improved and the above-mentioned digital front end has remained the same. LeeS said: ↑. Weirdly, the reviewer concluded that Vinyl is superior to SACD/DVD-A. Vinyl. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. Re: Super audio cd vs dvd audio. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Details;SACD VS Vinyl for Jazz and Classical Well, I've been thinking of getting into vinyl for a while now but still haven't done it. I prefer digital (CD, SACD, DVD-A, BDA) but not into streaming - trying to collect the band's material on disc (especially the 70s/80s era stuff). By all means, get the 4 DCC's. There are more albums where I compared against a standard CD. Well, I've been thinking of getting into vinyl for a while now but still haven't done it. SACD vs. After purchasing The Cars S/T, Candy-O, and Shake It Up on MFSL vinyl, here are my thoughts. . The SACD features the 2018 remix of the iconic 1977 Pink Floyd album for the first time, by long-time producer/engineer James Guthrie. But, Keith's drumming track seems lack lustre and 'dull', imo. Look how far CD sound has come in the last 20. Hard to say which sounds better, but they both sound very hard to top. I have 30 year old Sony belt drive TT with a SME 3 arm and blue point cartridge vs a Sony 777ES. Denon - DCD-A110 SACD/CD Player. . I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. There's no real difference between the sound characteristics of vinyl, SACD or CD. Stax, SACD vs. The SACD versions bring the best of the digital versions with the MOFI SACD followed by the 1999 SACD. To finish with the digital versions, the version in 360 (RA) Reality Audio brings a great rendering in 7. From the sound’s point of view, there is always a difference between SACD and the regular cd, but that left apart, usually XRCDs are sounding much better than. Todd68, Jun 30, 2019. SACD's can tend to have better mastering and transfer than standard CD releases of the same album. Today, the world has moved on to multi-bit PCM. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. The difference between DSD and the source vinyl was very, very slight and I am not sure I could tell the difference on any given day. 49:Personally I am fine with well mastered hi res digital. Recent MoFi controversy spurred me to compare sound of MoFi Vinyl to CD, SACD to CD, DSD to FLAC. The Beethoven symphony cycle on LSO Live (Haitink, 2006) is an SACD hybrid set. Low Noise Floor: SACDs tend to have a lower noise floor compared to vinyl records, which means less background noise or surface noise during playback. Label: Reprise: Genre: Pop/Rock: Product No. A SACD does sound better then a redbook CD. Since this is just for SACD vs SACD I'll start a thread on my preferred mastering for jazz and classical for all digital formats. SACD debate, there is no definitive answer to which format offers the ultimate listening experience. I'm generally rather selective about my SACD purchases and only have about 25-30SACD recordings now although I plan to order a lot more as more and more reissues come out. 3. I no longer have the capability of playing vinyl. Also, I believe Testikoff mentioned that the Shm transfer came from a master tape made for vinyl, which is not a good thing IMO. Gallery. More 'holographic', deeper staging. " The album topped the Billboard chart for a week, and remained on the chart for 741 weeks from 1973 to 1988. Tracks (7) Aja — Steely Dan's landmark sixth studio album reissue. Maybe no better overall than any other version. Although the MFSL version is very clear and precise, the SACD version is more expansive and full. I've not jumped on the SACD bandwagon. DVD-Audio vs Vinyl vs. It is a high-resolution digital. 4. I have SACD that beats my vinyl and vice versa. Doug Sax was also involved with the mastering of these CDs. So, Changes CD is DR 12 and Changes SACD is DR 11. Audiogon The world's largest high-end audio community. Dec 10, 2005. . These are the CDs that remastering was able to improve. Posted April 21, 2010. I listen mainly to vinyl via a Marantz TT15 Benz Wood SH MC combo. Limited Edition Numbered SACD CMOB 2260 SA $29. Quick links. I've a Sony XA7ES cd player that has served me well over the years, but even it doesn't get enough play to. You will enjoy the contrast and comparison. DJM first pressing vinyl from the UK best of all media. SACD vs. SACD vs. Although the MFSL version is very clear and precise, the SACD version is more expansive and full. This is the reason why Pink Floyd did NOT consider Alan Parsons. SACD vs. OTOH, there are many recordings from the 60s, 70s, and 80s that are of poor sound quality. Vinyl. The SHM-SACD is based off a copy tape and the HDTracks download is compressed. About 2 years ago, I decided to get back into vinyl. jupiterboy likes this. I, obviously, played the vinyl on my Clearaudio Concept TT. just WAY better than either the Blu-Spec CD or regular CD. Moody Blues "Question of bal. I'm getting older so no longer hear above 16kHz, so that means 320 kbps mp3 is pretty much transparent to me, as well as v0 vbr mp3. SACD vs. For Up, SACD is the one to get. By AJ Wykes • June 22, 2023 These days the vast majority of the music we experience is stored digitally. Should I buy the Deluxe edition for my Blu ray player that plays SACD or buy the Vinyl for an actual Vinyl player I would have to buy. Although the MFSL version is very clear and precise, the SACD version is more expansive and full. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. They are not cheap but not the most expensive of the DCC discs. The wait is over for the Analogue Productions SACD. The choice between the two depends on personal preferences and the desired. .